How to Start a Substack Newsletter People Want to Read
Starting a Substack takes a few minutes. Giving someone a reason to read your next email takes more thought.
The newsletters people return to make a clear promise. They might help a busy reader catch up on an industry, understand a difficult subject, or find an idea worth thinking about. Your job is to decide whose inbox you want to enter and what they should gain when your email arrives.
This guide walks through choosing a topic, setting up your Substack, finding your first readers and building a growth routine you can sustain. You will also find five newsletter examples and a 90-day plan.
Why do people read newsletters?
In a 2022 Reuters Institute survey of people who had recently accessed news by email across ten countries, 65% valued the convenience. Others cited a range of perspectives (30%), the author’s tone (28%) and content they could not find elsewhere (24%). These are news-email readers, not all newsletter subscribers, but their answers offer a useful starting point: make your email easy to use and worth choosing. Read the research.
Attention is limited. In a 2025 Pew Research Center survey, 62% of U.S. adults who get news from newsletters said they did not read most of the newsletters they received. A subscription is permission to send an email; every issue still has to earn attention. See Pew’s findings.
Questions to answer before you start a Substack
- Who is it for? Describe a real person and their situation: “freelance designers finding their first clients” is more useful than “people interested in business.”
- What will they get? Choose a benefit, such as a useful lesson, a concise briefing or an informed perspective.
- Why are you a good guide? Your advantage might be professional experience, careful research, access to a community or the questions you are willing to investigate. Be honest about what you know.
- What can you publish repeatedly? List 20 possible issues. If you struggle after five, revise the angle.
- Where will the first readers come from? Name actual communities, publications or platforms where your intended reader already spends time.
- What is the goal? You might want a creative practice, a professional reputation, a community or eventually a paid publication. The goal can change, but it should guide your choices now.
Write a one-sentence promise: “Every [frequency], I help [specific reader] [get a result] through [format or perspective].” For example: “Every Friday, I help independent designers find better clients through one practical outreach example.”
How to choose a newsletter niche
A niche is the meeting point of a reader, a recurring interest and your perspective. “Marketing” is broad. “Practical local SEO for independent home-service businesses” gives a reader a clearer reason to subscribe.
Score each idea against four questions: Can I write about it for six months? Can I find people discussing it? Can I contribute a useful perspective? Is the reader’s need recurring? A topic does not need a huge audience to be worthwhile. It does need enough people who care about the specific problem.
Talk to five potential readers before settling on a name. Ask what they are trying to learn, what they read now, and which questions keep coming up. Listen for the words they use. Offer two possible issue ideas and ask which they would open. Treat polite enthusiasm as a signal to investigate, not proof of demand.
Choose a format you can keep publishing
Pick a format that fits the reader’s need and the time you have. A roundup works when selection saves research time. A practical tutorial works when a reader wants to do something. An essay works when the value is your thinking. You can mix formats later, but start with one recognizable structure.
For a weekly practical newsletter, try: a short introduction, one problem, a worked example, one action to try, and a question readers can reply to. Write two complete issues before announcing a schedule. If each takes six hours you cannot spare, shorten the issue or publish less often.
How to set up your Substack newsletter
- Create your account and publication. Add a recognizable name, photo and short bio. Substack says new publications are public by default; check privacy settings if you need a private publication. See Substack’s setup guide.
- Write the description. Explain the audience, subject and expected frequency in plain language. Include one reason a reader should care.
- Set up your welcome experience. Tell new subscribers what to expect, point to a useful first issue and invite a reply. Where available, check the welcome page and subscription flow on a phone. Learn about the welcome page.
- Publish a useful first post. In the dashboard, choose Create and Article. Review the audience and delivery options before publishing: Substack can publish to the web and send by email and app inbox. Send yourself a test where available, and check the links. See the publishing steps.
- Invite subscribers with permission. Share your signup link with people who may find it useful. Import existing contacts only when you have appropriate permission and comply with applicable email rules.
Publishing is free according to Substack’s pricing page. If you enable paid subscriptions, Substack takes 10% of subscription revenue and payment processing charges apply; taxes and app-store pricing can vary. Verify payment availability in your country and current fees before committing to a paid launch.
Find your first readers without trying every channel
Start with one audience and one or two channels for six weeks. Choose the places where those readers already seek answers, then share something useful that stands on its own. A short post can explain one finding and link to the full issue for people who want more.
- LinkedIn: useful for professional topics. Share a lesson from a project, a small case study or a point of view, and invite interested readers to the newsletter.
- Search and your website: useful when people search for recurring problems. Publish a helpful article that answers one question and offers the newsletter as a relevant next step.
- Substack Notes: use short observations and thoughtful replies to meet readers and writers interested in the topic. Explain the idea in the post instead of sharing only a link.
- Communities and events: participate where you already have something to contribute. Follow group rules and offer an answer before mentioning your work.
- Other newsletters: read writers serving a related audience, then propose a useful guest contribution or collaboration when there is a genuine fit.
Substack’s writer partnerships team discusses recommendations as a way for publications to introduce readers to other writers. Recommend publications you would read yourself. Recommendations can help discovery, but a mention is not a guarantee of engaged subscribers.
Five newsletter examples and what to learn from them
These examples illustrate different ways to attract or retain an audience. Several are independent of Substack; their formats and distribution ideas can still be adapted. The observed tactics below are not proof that any single tactic caused their growth.
1. James Clear’s 3-2-1: make the format easy to share
3-2-1 gives readers three ideas from Clear, two quotes and one question each Thursday. His site also offers a substantial archive of articles. The repeatable structure explains what subscribers will receive; individual ideas can travel independently when readers share them.
Try it: create a recurring format that someone can describe in one sentence, then make each issue useful enough to forward. The format is a lesson in clarity, not a claim that it alone produced Clear’s audience.
2. SEOFOMO: own a specific professional need
SEOFOMO promises a weekly collection of SEO and AI-search updates, resources, tools and jobs. Its hub gives readers other reasons to return, including guides and a job board. Its positioning tells a search professional what problem the newsletter helps solve.
Try it: pick one professional audience, curate a small number of useful resources and add a sentence explaining why each matters. Build a resource page when you have enough material to maintain one.
3. Morning Brew: make referrals easy
Morning Brew’s referral FAQ describes a personal referral code and hub available from the newsletter. Its example shows how a publication can give existing readers a straightforward way to invite friends. A referral programme takes time and, if rewards are offered, money to administer.
Try it: start with a simple forwarding request and a clear signup link. Consider tracked rewards only when readers are already sharing and you can afford the fulfilment.
4. Lenny’s Newsletter: use relevant recommendations
In a 2023 Substack article, Lenny Rachitsky reported that 78% of his new subscribers at that time came from recommendations by other Substack newsletters. This is a dated, self-reported snapshot from an established publication, not a benchmark for new writers.
Try it: identify five publications with complementary audiences. Read them, contribute to the conversation and recommend those you genuinely trust. Give other writers a clear reason their readers would benefit from your work.
5. First 1000: combine a routine with experiments
Substack’s case study of First 1000 describes Ali Abouelatta combining regular publishing and promotion with experiments as the publication reached 20,000 subscribers. It is a publisher case study, so treat its lessons as ideas to test rather than guaranteed outcomes.
Try it: keep a simple experiment log. Record the channel, offer, time spent, signups and what you learned. Repeat the experiments that bring readers who stay engaged.
A practical 90-day newsletter growth plan
- Days 1–30: interview five readers, choose a promise, set up the publication and publish three issues. Share each with a relevant audience and ask what readers found useful.
- Days 31–60: keep the schedule manageable. Test two distribution channels and compare visits, signups and reader replies. Improve the welcome page if people visit but few subscribe.
- Days 61–90: double down on the channel bringing relevant subscribers. Try one collaboration, improve your most useful issue and ask readers what they want next.
These are planning targets, not subscriber guarantees. Track new subscribers, unsubscribes, signup source, replies and returning readers. Open rates can be distorted by privacy features, so use them as one signal alongside clicks and direct feedback. Judge a channel over several issues rather than one post.
Tools for creating and scaling a Substack
- Substack: publishing, email delivery, subscriber management, Notes and recommendations. Review which features fit your workflow.
- Canva: create a consistent cover image or simple diagram. Use visuals that help readers understand the issue, and provide descriptive alt text.
- A spreadsheet or notes app: keep a backlog of reader questions, issue ideas, sources and distribution experiments.
- Analytics: use Substack’s subscriber and post statistics to compare sources and engagement. Add website analytics if you also publish on your own site.
- Reader conversations: a reply prompt or short survey can reveal why someone subscribed and which questions remain unanswered.
As the publication grows, document how you research, edit and distribute each issue before hiring help. Keep the editorial decisions close to the person who understands the reader. Export subscriber and post data periodically using Substack’s subscriber export and publication export, and store personal data securely.
Frequently asked questions
Do I need an audience before starting a Substack?
No. Begin with people who already care about the subject: colleagues, communities or readers you reach through useful public work. Ask before adding anyone to your list.
How often should I publish?
Choose a schedule that gives you enough time to make each issue useful. Weekly is a reasonable experiment; twice a month may be a better fit for a research-heavy publication. Tell readers what to expect and adjust based on your capacity and their feedback.
Can I make money on Substack?
You can enable paid subscriptions if the payment service supports your location. Other approaches may include sponsorships, services or products, subject to platform rules and clear disclosures. Begin by understanding what your readers value and check current costs before setting prices.
What should my first newsletter include?
Briefly explain who you are, who the newsletter is for and what readers can expect. Then deliver one useful idea or example. End with a specific invitation to reply so you can learn about the people reading.
Start with your reader promise and a list of 20 issue ideas. Write the first two issues, show them to a few people in your intended audience, and use their feedback to improve the third.
